|
Partnership Programs:
American Revolution
Native American Series
Southeast Asian Tour
STEMTEC
Teachers as Scholars
Witness for Freedom
American Revolution:
Resources
{Books, lesson plans, links, videos, and
more}
Evaluations
{Read what the participants have to say about
each session.}
"To
Form a More Perfect Union" (PDF)
Read the article printed in Five College Ink magazine
about the series
(PDF files require Adobe
Acrobat Reader 4.0 to view. Download free program)
Participants (are
from the four collaborating districts, which include Belchertown,
Holyoke, Mohawk Trail and Hampshire Regional).
Judith Atwood, Peck Middle School
James Cannon, Dean Technical Voc. High School
Leny Jo Captein, Belchertown High School
Joe Coll, Hawlemont Regional Elementary School
Lynn Dole, Mohawk Trail Regional High School
Patricia Dostie-Hounshell, Lynch Middle School
Dana Geis, Lynch Middle School
Robert Hansbury, Belchertown High School
Jerry Hoyt, Mohawk Trail Regional High School
Edward O'Malley, Dean Technical Voc. High School
Helene Pajak, Westhampton Elementary School
Tracey Pinkham, Hampshire Regional Middle School
Steven Shepherd, Swift River Elementary School
Jane Shaney, Mohawk Trail Regional High School
Jason Woodcock, Belchertown High School
|
Theme: The Many Struggles for Citizenship, 1740-1840
Faculty: Joyce
Berkman, University of Massachusetts
The Declaration of Independence states that governments derive
their just powers "from the consent of the governed."
This radical concept repudiates the traditional idea of civic identity
as rooted in one's allegiance to the political ruler under whom
one was born. Presumably, the new and non-traditional Republic would
establish one's nationality and citizenship based upon one's consent,
rather than on accident of birth. But this was not to be.
From 1776 to the present, controversies have raged over the meaning
of national and civic identity and citizenship, over the rights
and obligations of citizens, and over who qualifies as a full citizen.
Ambiguous and exclusionary features of the US Constitution limited
the range of citizenship, spurring a multitude of court cases and
Amendments to the Constitution. Today we still have not resolved
the legal status of foreign immigrants, the offspring of illegal
immigrants, and the precise rights and obligations of women. The
citizenship rights of native born people of color continue precarious.
The session on Citizenship will focus on contradictions in the
assumptions and arguments of leaders of the American Revolution
and the framers of the Constitution regarding nationality and citizenship.
What are the sources of late eighteenth-century confusion over a
person's nationality and civic status? Why did this confusion prevail?
Why did social class, race and gender become contested axes of citizenship
rights and obligations? How did confusion over civic identity and
ideals become manifest during the Revolution's aftermath and eventually
within the Constitution? What is the legacy of this confusion? We
will look at specific court cases, e.g. Martin vs. Massachusetts
(1805) that disqualified women from independent civic identity,
a decision that historian Linda K. Kerber does not view as inevitable.
Is she correct?
· Warm-up: how issues of citizenship arise in our lives,
e.g., our receiving a notice of compulsory jury duty.
· In lecture format, an overview of the scholarship and its
findings on US citizenship and its relationship to issues of nationality,
gender, race, social class.
· Small groups: (a) examination of Primary Sources, e.g.
key articles of the Constitution, selected antebellum court cases,
iconography of active citizenship, diary accounts and letters.
· Small groups discuss how questions of US citizenship enter
into their current teaching of history and social studies. They
will compare their current classroom approaches to these questions
and consider as a result of their readings and the morning's discussion
what changes that they will try to adopt in the future.
(Reading List April 6, 2002)
Gundersen, Joan R., "Independence, Citizenship, and the American
Revolution" Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society,
Vol. 13, No. 1 (University of Chicago, 1987), pp.59-77.
Kerber, Linda K., "The Paradox of Women's Citizenship in the
Early Republic: The Case of Martin vs. Massachusetts, 1805",
American Historical Review, April, 1992 pp. 349-378.
Kerber, Linda K., "A Constitutional Right to be Treated Like
American Ladies: Women and the Obligations of Citizenship"
U.S. History as Women's History, (Chapel Hill: University of North
Carolina Press, 1995) pp17-35.
|